The Premier League Key Match Incidents panel has unanimously upheld the decision made by referee Chris Kavanagh and his Video Assistant Referee (VAR) team not to send off Arsenal defender Gabriel during the match against Chelsea on September 6, 2026. Arsenal won the game 2-1 at the Emirates Stadium amid some controversial decisions.
Read More
Notably, Riccardo Calafiori’s goal for Chelsea was disallowed for offside, while Kai Havertz’s equalizer was allowed to stand after a narrow offside call, both of which were supported unanimously by the panel with a 5-0 vote.
The incident involving Gabriel, which drew the most attention, occurred when he made contact with Chelsea goalkeeper Emi Martinez. While trying to play the ball, Gabriel's foot appeared to connect with Martinez’s head after he had secured the ball. The situation sparked considerable debate, with former professional players commenting on its severity.
Wayne Rooney stated on Match of the Day that Gabriel was "extremely lucky" not to be penalized. He remarked, "Martínez has got the ball, and he boots him on the head; I think he's extremely lucky to stay on the pitch." Ashley Young echoed these sentiments, questioning the lack of VAR review and saying, "I think he's got away with one there."
Despite the commentary, the Key Match Incidents panel reiterated that Gabriel’s action was not considered violent conduct or serious foul play, confirming the referee's original decision.